If the phrase workers’ comp audit makes your stomach drop, you're not alone. Most small business owners—especially those juggling payroll, compliance, and everything in between—see it as a red flag or worse, a penalty waiting to happen. The truth? It’s not a punishment. It’s a check-up, and with a little preparation, it can be no big deal.
Let’s break it down simply, so you can move from "What the heck is this?" to "I've got this."
First, let’s clear the air: this isn’t the IRS combing through your tax returns. A workers’ comp audit is when your insurance carrier reviews your actual payroll and job classifications to ensure you paid the right premium based on actual risk. That’s it. No hidden traps. No fines (unless something major is way off).
Insurance companies base your premium on estimated payroll for the year. But let’s be real—business changes. You might grow, hire more staff, or shift roles. The audit is a chance to reconcile the numbers and adjust the premium accordingly. You might even get money back if you overpaid. So yes, it’s worth getting right.
Most audits happen automatically when your policy renews. The insurance company wants to verify whether the payroll you projected aligns with what actually happened over the past year.
The second part they’re looking at? How employees are classified. Each role has a class code that reflects its risk. For example, an office admin and a delivery driver don’t pose the same liability. If someone is in the wrong bucket, it could result in under- or over-paying—and the audit is their way of fixing that.
You don’t need a three-ring binder, but having your ducks in a row is key. Typically, you'll need:
Having these ready means fewer follow-up calls and less back-and-forth.
You don’t need to scramble at audit time if you’ve been tracking properly all year. That means:
The cleaner your data, the quicker the process.
Ballparking numbers or rounding off figures isn’t just risky—it’s the #1 reason for audit stress. Use actual records. Your payroll provider or bookkeeper should be able to pull this info in minutes.
This happens more often than you’d think. Let’s say your marketing person starts helping out with customer deliveries. That shift in job duties may mean a different risk classification. If you don’t track that, it could mean penalties or back premiums.
And if you’re using family or part-time help? Yep, they count too.
You started your business to build something—not to get stuck worrying about insurance audits. With some thoughtful prep and a good payroll partner, audits can be a routine task instead of a source of anxiety.
Schedule a call with Cadence and let’s make sure you’re covered, confident, and audit-ready
Keep reading. Never stop learning.
4 min read
Workers' CompensationDo you need workers’ comp for 1099 contractors? Probably not—but misclassification can cost you. Learn when coverage is required and how to stay compliant
Founder
3 min read
Workers' CompensationNew to workers’ comp? Learn what small business owners need to know—who needs coverage, how to get it, what it costs, and how Cadence can help you stay compliant.
Founder
4 min read
Workers' CompensationGet clarity on workers’ comp—from coverage setup to claims and audits. Learn what to expect and how CadenceHCM helps you stay compliant and stress-free.
Founder